Educational guide · Debt relief

What every veteran should know about debt relief

Debt relief covers several very different paths, each with its own costs and risks. Here is how they compare, which military protections may apply, and how to spot a bad offer.

On this page9 sections
  1. Start with what you can do yourself
  2. Credit counseling and debt management plans
  3. How debt settlement works
  4. Bankruptcy
  5. Protections for servicemembers
  6. What VA debt help covers
  7. Red flags and vetting
  8. Questions to ask any provider
  9. Sources
A couple in their fifties reviews bills with a calculator at a sunny farmhouse kitchen table.
How we make money

Honorable Veterans is an advertising-supported comparison site. If you choose to be connected with a partner, we may be paid by that partner. This guide is educational, written to our editorial standards, and partners do not review or pay for it. See our advertising disclosure.

"Debt relief" is a broad label. It can mean a phone call to your card issuer, a structured plan through a nonprofit counselor, a negotiated settlement, or a bankruptcy filing. Those options carry very different levels of risk to your credit, your budget, and your taxes. This guide walks through them roughly in order from lowest to highest risk, then covers protections that may apply to servicemembers and the warning signs worth knowing before you sign anything.

Start with what you can do yourself

The lowest-risk step usually costs nothing. The Federal Trade Commission points out that you do not need to pay a company to talk to your credit card company for you; you can contact creditors yourself, for free.1

Before you call, it can help to:

  • List every debt with its balance, interest rate, minimum payment, and due date.
  • Build a realistic monthly budget so you know what you can actually pay.
  • Ask each creditor whether it offers a hardship program, a lower rate, or a modified payment schedule.
  • Write down who you spoke with, the date, and what was offered, and ask for any new terms in writing.

Creditors are not required to say yes, but asking costs nothing and may surface options you did not know about. If you are currently serving, also read the section on military protections below before you call, because a federal rate cap may apply to some older debts.

Nonprofit credit counseling and debt management plans

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau suggests considering a nonprofit credit counseling service, which may help you build a budget and work with your creditors on a debt management plan.2 In a plan, you deposit money each month with the counseling organization, which uses it to pay your unsecured debts under the agreed payment plan.1

These plans take commitment. The FTC notes that a debt management plan may take 48 months or more to complete.1 The FTC also cautions that nonprofit status alone does not mean a service is free, affordable, or legitimate, and that some counseling organizations charge high fees they may not disclose up front.1 Ask about every fee before you enroll.

Common debt relief paths, from lower to higher risk (general overview, not advice)
OptionWhat it involvesMain trade-offs
Calling creditors yourselfAsking for hardship terms or a lower rateNo fee; creditors may decline
Debt management planOne monthly payment through a credit counselorMay take 48 months or more; fees vary
Debt settlementA company negotiates to pay less than you oweCredit harm, fees, possible taxes, no assurance creditors agree
BankruptcyA federal court process under Chapter 7 or Chapter 13Long-term credit impact; legal and filing costs

How debt settlement works, and its risks

Debt settlement companies try to negotiate with your creditors so you pay less than the full balance. The FTC explains that these programs generally have you set aside money each month in a designated account, and often encourage you to stop paying your creditors in the meantime.1 That gap in payments is where much of the risk comes from. The FTC lists several concerns:1

  • Creditors do not have to agree. There is no rule that forces a creditor to settle.
  • Credit damage and fees. Stopping payments can lead to late fees and hurt your credit.
  • Many people do not finish. Staying in a program long enough to settle every debt can be hard.

The CFPB adds that settlement companies often charge expensive fees and that forgiven debt could count as taxable income.2 The IRS explains that canceled debt is generally taxable unless an exception or exclusion applies, such as bankruptcy or insolvency, and that creditors often report canceled debt on Form 1099-C.3 If you settle a debt, it may be worth talking with a tax professional about how the canceled amount is treated.

Results vary widely. No honest provider can tell you in advance exactly how much any creditor will accept or how long it will take.

Bankruptcy: a legal process to discuss with an attorney

Bankruptcy is a federal court process, not a product. The FTC describes the two main types of personal bankruptcy: Chapter 13, which generally lets you keep property while you follow a repayment plan, and Chapter 7, which involves selling assets that are not exempt.1 The FTC also notes that bankruptcy is generally treated as a last option because of its long-term effect on credit, that bankruptcy information can stay on your credit report for 10 years, and that filing fees and attorney fees add to the cost.1

There are procedural steps, too. According to the U.S. Trustee Program at the Department of Justice, individuals generally must complete credit counseling before filing, and must complete a separate debtor education course after filing to receive a discharge, with limited exceptions. Both courses come from providers approved by the U.S. Trustee Program.9

Whether bankruptcy makes sense depends on your income, assets, and the kinds of debt you have. This guide is not legal advice. If you are considering it, talk with a qualified bankruptcy attorney licensed in your state.

Protections that may apply to servicemembers

Two federal laws can matter a great deal if you are serving or recently served.

The SCRA 6% interest rate cap

Under the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act, eligible servicemembers can ask to cap interest at 6% per year on debts taken out before entering military service, such as credit cards, car loans, student loans, and mortgages. The Department of Justice explains that the request must be in writing with a copy of your orders, and must be made no later than 180 days after your service ends.6 If this applies to you, it may be worth sending those requests before paying anyone for debt help.

The Military Lending Act 36% limit

The Military Lending Act generally limits many types of consumer credit for active-duty servicemembers and their covered dependents to a Military Annual Percentage Rate of 36%. According to the CFPB, it does not cover residential mortgages or auto loans secured by the vehicle being bought.7

What VA debt help covers, and what it does not

You may see the VA mentioned alongside debt relief, which can be confusing. VA's debt help options are for debts owed to VA itself, such as benefit overpayments, which are handled by the VA Debt Management Center, and VA health care copays, which are handled separately.8 They are not a program for credit card balances or other private consumer debt.

If you owe money to VA, go straight to VA's website to learn about your options. Private debt relief companies, including the providers on our site, are not part of any VA or government program, and you can contact VA directly about a VA debt.

Red flags and how to vet a provider

Federal rules give you a useful test. Under the FTC's Telemarketing Sales Rule, a debt relief company that sells its services by phone generally cannot collect fees until it has settled or changed the terms of at least one of your debts and you have made at least one payment under that new agreement.4 The FTC says this rule also covers calls you make in response to ads, including TV, direct mail, and online ads.5

Warning signs to watch for:

  • A request for fees before any debt has been settled or changed.
  • Promises of a specific percentage cut, a fixed timeline, or that your debt will simply go away.
  • Claims of a connection to the VA or another government agency.
  • Advice to stop talking to your creditors without explaining the consequences.
  • Pressure to sign right away or reluctance to put terms in writing.

To vet a provider, the FTC suggests checking with your state attorney general and local consumer protection agency for complaints, and asking whether companies must be licensed in your state and, if so, whether the one you are considering is.1 Licensing rules vary by state. Read the full written agreement, including every fee and how it is calculated, before you enroll.

Questions to ask any provider

  • What are all of your fees, when are they charged, and how are they calculated?
  • Do you collect any fee before a debt is settled or its terms are changed?
  • Are you licensed or registered in my state? Can you give me the license number?
  • Which of my debts can this program address, and which can it not?
  • What happens to my credit and to late fees if I stop paying creditors?
  • What happens if a creditor refuses to negotiate or sues me?
  • Can I leave the program at any time, and what happens to money I have set aside?
  • Have you looked at whether the SCRA rate cap or a hardship program could help me first?
  • May I have the complete agreement in writing to read before I sign?

Honorable Veterans is not a debt settlement company, law firm, credit counselor, or lender. Programs are not right for everyone, results vary, and fees may apply with providers.

Sources

Debt relief programs are not right for everyone. Results vary, programs can affect your credit, fees may apply with providers, and forgiven debt may be taxable. No outcome or timeline is promised.